Which material seal is best for a hydraulic system?

Introduction to Hydraulic System Seals

Hydraulic systems are integral to various machinery and equipment across multiple industries. They rely heavily on hydraulic seals to ensure operational efficiency and prevent fluid leakage. Hydraulic seals maintain the pressure within the system while keeping contaminants at bay. Given the critical role they play, selecting the right material for hydraulic seals is paramount. This article will delve into the pros and cons of different seal materials, focusing on their compatibility with various fluids and operating conditions.

Commonly Used Seal Materials

● Acrylonitrile Butadiene Rubber (NBR)

One of the most frequently used materials in hydraulic seals is

● Acrylonitrile Butadiene Rubber (NBR)

. NBR is renowned for its excellent resistance to petroleum-based hydraulic fluids, making it a popular choice for hyd cylinder seal kits. It can operate efficiently within a temperature range of -50°C to 120°C (-60°F to 250°F) and up to 150°C (300°F) for shorter periods.

○ Compatible Fluids

- Petroleum-based hydrocarbons
- Mineral oils
- Diesel and fuel oils
- Vegetable oils

○ Incompatible Fluids

- Highly aromatic hydrocarbons
- Ketones
- Acetic acid
- Strong acids

● Fluorocarbon Rubber (FKM)

Fluorocarbon Rubber, commonly known as Viton, is another widely used material for hydraulic seals. FKM can withstand a broader temperature range from -40°C to 200°C (-40°F to 400°F), making it suitable for more rigorous applications.

○ Compatible Fluids

- Petroleum-based hydrocarbons
- Synthetic hydraulic fluids
- Fuel mixtures including gasoline and alcohol
- Many organic solvents

○ Incompatible Fluids

- Glycol-based brake fluids
- Strong alkalis
- Amines and ammonia
- Formic and acetic acids

● Thermoplastic Polyurethanes (TPU)

TPU is used for specialized apps where extreme wear resistance and flexibility are required. This material is often employed in hyd cylinder seal kits supplied by leading hyd cylinder seal kit manufacturers for use with bio-hydraulic fluids.

○ Advantages

- Excellent wear resistance
- High flexibility
- Suitable for bio-hydraulic fluids

○ Limitations

- Limited chemical resistance
- Not suitable for high-temperature applications

● Compatibility

of NBR Seals

NBR seals, also known as Buna-N seals, offer a robust solution for hydraulic systems using petroleum-based fluids. These seals are affordable and provide good performance across a wide range of temperatures, making them a common choice for high quality hyd cylinder seal kits from reputable hyd cylinder seal kit suppliers.

● Temperature Range

- Operational: -50°C to 120°C (-60°F to 250°F)
- Short-term use: Up to 150°C (300°F)

○ Incompatible Fluids

NBR seals work well with a variety of hydraulic fluids, including mineral oils and diesel. However, they are not suitable for highly aromatic hydrocarbons, ketones, strong acids, or glycol-based brake fluids.

○ Advantages

of Using FKM Seals

FKM seals, or Viton seals, are another excellent choice for hydraulic systems, especially those exposed to a wide range of temperatures and chemicals. These seals are costlier than NBR seals, but their performance often justifies the higher price.

● Temperature Tolerance

- Wide range: -40°C to 200°C (-40°F to 400°F)

● Types of FKM

- Type A: Common and cost-effective
- Type G: Improved fluid compatibility and resistance to ozone and weathering

● Compatibility

FKM seals are compatible with petroleum-based hydrocarbons, synthetic fluids, and many organic solvents but are unsuitable for glycol-based brake fluids and strong alkalis.

Specialized Applications with TPU Seals

● Thermoplastic Polyurethanes (TPU)

are increasingly utilized in hydraulic systems requiring seals that offer both high flexibility and wear resistance. TPU is especially effective in applications involving bio-hydraulic fluids, where other seal materials might not perform as well.

○ Advantages

- Superior wear resistance
- High degree of flexibility

● Compatibility

with bio-hydraulic fluids

○ Limitations

While TPU seals are advantageous in terms of wear resistance and flexibility, they have limited chemical resistance and are not suitable for environments involving high temperatures.

Impact of Hydraulic Fluid Base Oils on Seals

Hydraulic fluid base oils can significantly affect the performance and longevity of seals. Understanding the different types of base oils and their interactions with seal materials is crucial for making informed decisions.

● API Group I, II, III, IV, V Base Oils

- Group I: Solvent-refined, commonly used.
- Group II and III: Hydroprocessed, offering superior oxidation resistance.
- Group IV: Polyalphaolefins (PAO).
- Group V: Include naphthenic mineral oils, polyalkylene glycol (PAG), and synthetic esters.

● Additives

in hydraulic fluids can enhance specific properties but also introduce potential interactions with seal materials, affecting their performance and longevity.

Predicting Fluid and Seal Material Behavior

Predicting the interaction between hydraulic fluids and seal materials helps in selecting the best seals.

● Aniline Point Method

Comparing the aniline point of the fluid to that of standard reference oils helps estimate fluid/seal compatibility.


● Compatibility

Index (ECI)
The ECI method compares the behavior of a standard NBR compound in various oils, providing a more accurate prediction of fluid-seal interactions.

Selecting the Right Seal Material for Applications

Given the wide range of variables, selecting the right seal material requires careful consideration. It's advisable to seek guidance from manufacturers when making decisions about seal materials, particularly in specialized applications.

● Manufacturer Guidance

Consulting with hyd cylinder seal kit manufacturers can offer insights into which materials are best suited for specific applications, ensuring optimal performance and longevity.

● Replacement Considerations

Before replacing seals, consider the potential impact of hydraulic fluid changes on the existing seals to avoid operational issues and unnecessary expenses.

Cost-Effectiveness of Seal Choices

Choosing the right seal involves balancing cost and performance. While NBR seals are often the most cost-effective, FKM seals may offer better longevity and performance in specific applications, justifying their higher cost.

● Cost vs. Performance

- NBR: Affordable, suitable for most applications.
- FKM: Higher cost, better for extreme conditions.

● When to Change Materials

For existing systems, it's usually unnecessary to switch to higher-cost materials unless the current seals exhibit unusual failure modes or shortened service lives.

Conclusion and Best Practices

Selecting the right seal material for hydraulic systems is a critical consideration that impacts system efficiency, performance, and longevity. NBR and FKM are commonly used materials, each offering unique advantages and limitations. NBR seals are cost-effective and suitable for many applications, while FKM seals provide broader temperature tolerance and superior chemical resistance.

For specialized applications, materials like TPU may be more appropriate. Consult with reputable hyd cylinder seal kit suppliers to ensure optimal material selection for your specific needs. Regularly review the compatibility of hydraulic fluids with your seals to maintain operational integrity.

About Borise

Hangzhou Ruiwei Machinery Equipment Co., Ltd., under the brand BORISE, is a leading professional sealing system supplier. We specialize in the design and production of polyurethane oil seals, offering high resilience and excellent wear resistance. With our German-engineered R&D, we cater to diverse construction machinery sealing needs, ensuring top-notch quality and performance. Borise continues to set industry standards with its commitment to innovation and excellence.

For more information and to explore our range of high-quality hyd cylinder seal kits, visit our website or contact us directly.Which material seal is best for a hydraulic system?
Post time: 2024-07-09 15:06:04
  • Previous:
  • Next:
  • Leave Your Message